The Bahamas wasn’t exactly a paradise for the Southern Charm cast during their visit, as tensions ran high in the Feb. 27 episode.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749x0:751x2):format(webp)/shep-rose-sienna-evans-craig-conover-tout-022725-7a3ae4340aa849a6921ef57a40233924.jpg)
Jarrett “JT” Thomas arrived in the Bahamas, where the cast had been visiting Shep Rose’s rumored girlfriend, Sienna Evans. Almost immediately, he clashed with his costars, particularly Craig Conover. The two got into a heated debate about whether JT had called Patricia Altschul a “bitch” and his remarks regarding Madison LeCroy. Shep sided with JT, adding fuel to the fire, and the argument upset Venita Aspen, who felt helpless watching her best friend get verbally attacked.
After dinner, things took an unexpected turn when Venita and JT spent time alone in his hotel room. Venita made her feelings known, admitting she straddled JT and told him, “Don’t act like you don’t want this just as bad as I do.” JT, however, made it clear that he wasn’t interested in anything beyond friendship. Despite her advances, he firmly rejected her, even physically moving her off him twice. “That’s not easy as a guy to do,” JT said, expressing how challenging the situation was for him.
Meanwhile, Shep, Craig, and Whitney Sudler-Smith tried to unwind at the resort casino, but Shep’s behavior escalated. According to Craig, Shep was so drunk that he was kicked out for being “unable to stand up.” Afterward, Shep went missing, and Craig and Whitney searched for him for hours. The next morning, Shep confessed that he had spiraled due to the drama with Sienna and ended up sleeping on a beach. “Nothing bad happened,” he reassured Craig.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(499x0:501x2):format(webp)/Venita-Aspen-jt-thomas-010925-a60c0ed1e5e84b07935ae19e6aa14fd2.jpg)
The group was growing increasingly concerned about Shep’s relationship with Sienna, especially after she repeatedly avoided him. Despite sending her a long text outlining his feelings, Shep was left wondering if he even deserved to be in a relationship. His friends, including Craig and Paige DeSorbo, urged him to let go if Sienna wasn’t reciprocating the same energy. Paige, offering advice from her mother, told Shep, “If they liked you, you would know it,” further encouraging him to move on.
Sienna’s absence continued, as she bailed on the group’s boat trip to Rose Island, along with JT. JT, commenting on the situation, said, “I see mission impossible right now with the friend group.” He also noted the escalating tension with Venita, which he was determined to squash.
Though Shep joined the boat trip, his mood was far from upbeat. Reflecting on his past, he expressed doubts about his worth in a relationship, wondering, “Who the f— am I?” He acknowledged the damage his wild behavior had caused in previous relationships, feeling inadequate in comparison to others who were seeking stability.
Despite his internal struggle, Madison LeCroy reassured Shep that he deserved love, though the unraveling of his relationship with Sienna left him in a deep period of self-reflection.